Why is a tear-off usually the answer on an old house?
On a house with two or three layers and an unknown deck, a tear-off is the only way to be sure the boards beneath are sound and the flashing is sealed to the right layer.
An overlay hides the condition it is meant to fix. Nail heads sit on top of earlier nails, rot stays out of sight, and a wall flashing that was set under the old shingles can end up above the new ones. Stripping the roof takes longer, but it lets the crew correct the deck and set every joint to the current work rather than to the work of thirty years ago.
What does the deck tell a roofer?
The underside of the boards records years of water, heat and movement, and a roofer reads it before deciding how much of the deck to renew.
Dark rings around nails, a soft edge at a valley, and a rafter stained on one face each point to a different history. Board sheathing that has been wet for years tends to swell and warp, while plywood that fails usually does so at its edges. Those signs decide where the cutting starts, and the scope notes every span that was renewed.
How is the permit question settled?
Permits are a town matter, and the answer for a given house comes from the building department of the town it stands in, not from a general rule about roofs.
Sources disagree on when a re-roof needs a permit, and the rules have been written differently for different kinds of work, so this page does not state a threshold. Ask the local building department before the job is scheduled. The state building code, 780 CMR, tenth edition, took effect on 11 October 2024, and a crew should be able to say which edition it is working to on the day.
What should a written scope include?
A useful scope lists the layers removed, the deck work, the underlayment and membrane locations, the flashing, the shingle product by type, and the warranty period on the labor.
It should also say what happens if the deck is worse than the inspection suggested, because that is the most common change in the middle of a job. A clear rule, such as the crew stops and calls before renewing more than a stated amount of sheathing, keeps the homeowner in control without slowing the work on the day.