The barrier across the Acushnet River closes for high tides and coastal storms, and it protects low ground from surge. It does not stop wind, rain or snow, and the roof on a New Bedford house takes all three in the same storms the barrier closes for.
Key takeaways
- The barrier holds back storm surge, the water that rises over low ground, and it was built for that hazard alone.
- Wind, wind-driven rain and snow reach a roof whether or not the gates are closed, and the roof is the part of the house they act on first.
- The 1938 hurricane and Carol in 1954 each pushed a surge of roughly 12 to 14 feet, and both came before the barrier was built.
- Hurricane Bob in 1991 brought sustained winds of 75 to 100 mph across most of southeastern Massachusetts, which is a wind test no barrier was designed to meet.
- A closure tells you high water was expected, not what happened to the covering, the flashing or the attic.
- Plan the roof as a separate system from the barrier, with its own checks after every storm.
When was the barrier built, and what does it cover?
Construction ran from 1962 into 1966, and the barrier protects more than a thousand acres across New Bedford, Fairhaven and Acushnet.
The hurricane barrier was built across the mouth of the Acushnet River between 1962 and early 1966, and it was dedicated on 21 May 1966. It is a little over three miles long, and it was built to keep storm surge out of the low ground where the river meets Buzzards Bay.
The protected area takes in more than a thousand acres across New Bedford, Fairhaven and Acushnet. Much of that ground is low, flat and close to the water, which is why surge was the hazard the barrier was designed against and why the houses behind it still need their own protection from weather.
The gates close for high tides and for coastal storms, and across a typical year that happens many times. Residents who live behind the barrier see closures as routine, which is exactly why the roof side of the risk is so easy to forget.
What did the big storms do to this coast?
The 1938 hurricane and Carol in 1954 each pushed a surge of about 12 to 14 feet, and Bob in 1991 added sustained winds that reached the roofs.
Sources disagree on the exact readings for the 1938 hurricane and for Carol in 1954, so this guide gives the range rather than a single figure. Both storms produced a surge of roughly 12 to 14 feet at the coast, and neither had the barrier to meet it, because the barrier did not yet exist.
Hurricane Bob crossed southeastern New England in August 1991. The National Weather Service in Boston recorded a surge of 10 to 15 feet into Buzzards Bay, with the highest readings of 12 to 15 feet at Onset, Bourne, Mashpee and Wareham. Sustained winds of 75 to 100 mph reached across most of southeastern Massachusetts, and most residents in the region lost power.
For a roof, the difference between surge and wind is the one that matters. Surge floods the ground floor and the cellar. Wind takes the covering off the roof and the flashing off the chimney, and it does so on high ground as well as low, where no barrier was ever needed.
What does the barrier not stop?
The barrier stops surge. It does not stop wind, wind-driven rain or snow, and it was never designed to.
Read the barrier as one line of defense for the low ground and nothing more. A house on the higher side of the river can lose its shingles in a strong northeast gale with the gates wide open, and a closed barrier does nothing to change that outcome.
Wind is the hazard that acts on the roof itself. It lifts the edge of the covering, works on a loose nail until it pulls through, and finds the joint at a chimney or a dormer where the flashing has already lost its seal. Once the covering moves, rain follows the path of least resistance into the attic.
Snow is a separate matter. The roof under a heavy load is judged by its framing, its drainage and its ice protection, and none of those is affected by the gates on the river. A roof can be sound through a surge and still fail under a wet snow that a barrier would never have been asked to hold back.
Why are older roofs in this area more exposed?
Many houses here are old, tall and close together, so the roof takes more wind and more water at the flashing than a newer, lower house would.
Much of the city's housing predates the Second World War, and those roofs were framed for the wind and the weather of their own time. Many carry coverings and flashing details that have been patched rather than rebuilt, and a patch that held in an ordinary season can lift in a storm.
Triple-decker roofs are exposed on three sides at height. The wall and the roof edge take the wind together, and the flat or low-slope deck at the top collects water that a steep roof would simply shed. The problem is structural as well as weatherproofing, because the water sits where the framing is weakest.
Coastal lots carry a different exposure. Salt-laden air and open water to the south mean that metal, fasteners and sealants wear faster than they do a few miles inland. That is a reason to inspect after every large storm, not only when a leak finally shows on a ceiling.
What should a roof be checked for after a storm?
Look for lifted or missing covering, displaced flashing, bent metal and debris on the roof, then check the attic for wet insulation and staining.
Start from the ground without climbing. Look for shingles or pieces of covering in the yard, bent or missing metal at the edges, a chimney cap that has moved, and any tree limb resting on the roof. Those signs are visible from the street and tell you where to look first.
Then check the attic with a flashlight once the wind has dropped and it is safe to enter. Look for light showing through the deck, damp insulation, dark staining on the underside of the sheathing and any wet rafter where a valley or dormer meets the roof.
A written inspection should record each finding with a photograph and a note of anything that could not be seen. A repair scope that starts from the stain without finding its source is a repair that is likely to be redone.
Is a barrier closure a reason to call a roofer?
A closure shows that a surge was expected, not what happened to the roof, so a call after the storm is about the roof itself.
The gates closing is a public event, reported by the city and the weather service, but it does not describe damage. A roof can come through a storm that closed the barrier with no harm at all, and a roof can fail in a wind event that never came near the surge line.
The useful questions for a homeowner are whether water is reaching the living space, whether covering is loose, and when the roof was last inspected. Those three answers decide whether a visit is needed this week or can wait for the next scheduled check.
If you are unsure, call (833) 751-2102 and describe what you can see. A call that names the chimney, the valley or the stained ceiling helps the roofer plan the visit so that the first trip is the right one.
Which roof details fail first?
The details that fail first are usually the ones that already failed in the last storm: flashing at the chimney, valleys, skylights and any metal edge that has lifted once.
A roof that has been repaired at a weak point is not automatically sound there. Repairs at chimneys and valleys are the places a second storm tests again, and a patch that was never tied into the surrounding courses will lift before the rest of the roof does.
Skylights and dormers are the next most common failure after the storm has passed. The seal around a skylight frame is pushed by wind, and a dormer cheek that has been bent once rarely returns to its original line, so water finds the gap.
Metal edges are the quiet failure. A drip edge or a rake flashing that lifts by an inch lets wind-driven rain behind the covering, and the water reaches the decking before anyone notices the metal has moved.
What should planning for the next storm include?
Planning means knowing which details fail first, keeping a dated record of the roof and having a roofer who can arrive quickly after a storm.
Keep records. A dated photograph of the roof and the attic, taken in a calm season, is the baseline a roofer can compare against after the next storm. It turns a dispute about what was damaged into a comparison of two sets of pictures, which is a much shorter conversation.
Plan the roof as well as the barrier. The gates protect the low ground, and the roof protects the house and everything in it. The roof needs its own schedule of checks, its own repairs and its own record, and none of those depends on whether the gates were closed.
Choose a roofer before you need one. A company that already knows the house, its roof and its earlier repairs can plan a post-storm visit faster and with the right materials, which matters when many roofs in the city need attention on the same day.
Frequently asked questions
Does the hurricane barrier protect roofs?
It protects against storm surge, which is water rising over the low ground. It does not protect a roof from wind, wind-driven rain or snow, and houses on higher ground are not sheltered by a closure at all.
How often does the barrier close?
Often enough that closures are routine, for high tides and for coastal storms. A closure is a sign of high water, not a measure of roof damage, so it should not be read as a reason the roof is fine or a reason it is broken.
Did the 1938 hurricane and Carol flood this area?
Both brought a surge of roughly 12 to 14 feet to the coast, and the barrier was not yet built for either storm. Sources differ on the exact readings, so the range is the honest figure to use.
Should I inspect my roof when the barrier closes?
Inspect after any storm that brings strong wind, whether or not the gates closed. The closure is a warning about surge, and the roof needs checking for wind damage, which can happen on high ground where nothing floods.
What should I say when I call about storm damage?
Describe what you see from the ground and any water inside: the location of the stain, any missing covering, the time of the storm and whether the attic is wet. Those details decide how quickly a crew can plan the visit.
This guide is general information for Bristol County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.