Phones answered 24/7New Bedford, MA
Call (833) 751-2102
Phones answered 24/7Call any time(833) 751-2102
Guide

What the bay wind does to a shingle, and why the shore takes it first

How wind off Buzzards Bay loads shingles and metal on South Coast roofs, what Hurricane Bob showed in 1991, and what to check on an exposed shore house.

Illustration for the guide "What the bay wind does to a shingle, and why the shore takes it first" (New Bedford, MA)
Short answer

Buzzards Bay lies to the south of the city and the shore towns, and a wind off the water reaches a roof with little to slow it. Hurricane Bob in 1991 brought sustained winds of 75 to 100 mph across most of southeastern Massachusetts. This guide explains how that load reaches a shingle and where the covering lets go first.

Key takeaways

  • Open water gives the wind a long run and little friction, so a shore roof takes gusts at close to full strength.
  • A gale that turns across the bay can load a side of the house that has been sheltered for years.
  • The eave, the rake edges, the ridge and the gable corners carry the highest uplift, and they are the first places a covering lifts.
  • A lifted shingle is a repair call, because the gap it leaves lets rain reach the underlayment and the deck.
  • Metal, slate and wood coverings respond to bay wind differently, and each needs its own attachment check.
  • After a bay storm, check all four sides of the roof and the attic beneath the windward edge, not only the side you can see from the street.

Why is shore wind harder on a roof than inland wind?

Open water gives the wind a long run and little friction, so the gusts that reach a shore roof are stronger and less broken up than those inland.

Wind over open water meets little resistance, and it reaches a shore roof without the trees and buildings that slow it farther inland. The roof takes the wind at close to full strength on its windward side, and the covering at the eave and the ridge sees the greatest load.

The shoreline also changes direction. A gale that backs or veers across the bay can strike a house from a side it has never faced, lifting an edge of covering that was sheltered from every earlier wind. A roof that survived one direction has not proven it will survive the next.

Salt air adds a slower wear. Salt-laden wind and spray settle on metal, on fasteners and on the surface of the covering, and the damage shows up as corrosion and loose fixings long before the wind has done anything dramatic.

What did Hurricane Bob show in 1991?

Bob's sustained winds of 75 to 100 mph reached across most of southeastern Massachusetts, and its surge was highest where the bay meets the shore.

Hurricane Bob crossed southeastern New England in August 1991. Sustained winds of 75 to 100 mph reached across most of southeastern Massachusetts, and most of the region lost power. The wind did roof damage that the water never reached, and the two hazards should be planned for separately.

The coastal towns took the surge as well. The National Weather Service in Boston recorded the highest readings, 12 to 15 feet, at Onset, Bourne, Mashpee and Wareham. A house on a shore lot in that band faced the water and the wind in the same storm, and its roof had to hold against both.

Bob is the reference point for this coast, and a roof on a shore lot should be judged against what it came through in that storm rather than against an ordinary year. If the covering or the flashing failed then, a repair is not finished until the cause has been understood and corrected.

How does wind lift a shingle?

Wind gets under the edge of a shingle, lifts the tab and works the nail heads until the fastener pulls through or the sealant lets go.

Asphalt shingles are held by nails and a strip of sealant, and the wind's first target is the exposed edge and the corners. Once the tab lifts, the wind gets underneath it and pulls harder, and the lift travels along the course until the tab tears or the fastener gives way.

Nail placement matters. A nail set high in the shingle or driven at an angle holds less than one set in its proper place, and a roof nailed too few times per shingle relies on the sealant alone. Once the seal is lost, the shingle has nothing left to stop it lifting in the next gust.

Wind alone seldom takes a whole roof. More often it creates a gap, and the rain that follows works in through that gap to the underlayment and the deck beneath. That is why a single lifted shingle on a bay house is a repair call, not a cosmetic one, and why it should be reset before the next weather front.

Which parts of a shore roof fail first?

The eave, the rake edges, the ridge and the corners of a gable take the highest load, and the flashing at any penetration is the next weak point.

The edges and corners of a roof carry the greatest uplift in a storm. The eave, the rake edge where the roof meets the gable wall and the ridge cap are the first places covering lifts, and a lost ridge cap exposes the top courses to every later rain.

Ridge and hip caps, drip edge and starter strips are the small pieces that hold the edges down. They are simple to replace when they are found early, and far harder to restore once the damage has spread under the covering, which is why they belong on every post-storm checklist.

Flashing at chimneys, skylights and dormers comes next. Wind-driven rain pushes past flashing that is only just holding, and the leak appears inside the house days after the storm, long after the roof looked fine from the street.

What about metal and other coverings near the bay?

Metal, slate and wood each respond to bay wind differently, and each needs its own attachment check rather than a shingle check alone.

Metal roofing is attached by clips, screws or seams, and it moves in the wind. On the bay, the concern is fastening and finish, because salt and spray work on screws and seams first, and a loose panel is noisy long before it is lost.

Padanaram Village in South Dartmouth is a district on the National Register of Historic Places, listed in 1985, and cedar shingle is common on its walls. Dartmouth survey records often describe asphalt shingle roofs there. Check which covering a given roof actually has before choosing a repair method.

Slate and wood shake shed wind well when they are intact and sound, but a cracked slate or a split shake is an open path for water. A lifted row can be hard to see from the ground, and a surface that looks whole can still hide fasteners that have worked loose.

How should a shore roof be inspected?

An inspection checks the edges, the fastening, the flashing and the attic beneath, and records each one with photographs.

Walk the perimeter from the ground first and look for missing or creased covering, lifted edges and gaps along the ridge. Then use a ladder, with care, to check the eave and the rake edges up close, where the tabs lift most often.

In the attic, look at the underside of the sheathing near the eave, the ridge and each penetration for stains, dark edges and damp insulation. An old, dry stain is a different finding from one that is still wet, and the roofer should say which it is and how it was judged.

Record the findings with dated photographs. A roof on the bay will be inspected again after the next storm, and a dated record turns a general worry into a comparison that can be checked by anyone who reads the file.

What should a homeowner do after a bay storm?

Check from the ground, look at the attic within a day or two, and call for a visit if any covering is loose or any water is found.

Start with a walk around the house. Pick up any shingle or metal pieces in the yard, note the position of anything that has moved, and look for a loose gutter or a shifted chimney cap. Those signs point to where the roof was hit, and they take no time to record.

Then check the attic with a light, once it is safe to enter. Water that appeared during the storm should be noted with its exact location, and any wet insulation should be photographed before it is disturbed or removed.

Call (833) 751-2102 when there is a leak, a loose tab or any missing covering. Describe what you saw and when the wind was strongest, and a crew can plan the visit with the right materials in hand.

How does a shore lot change the choice of repair?

Exposure on a shore lot argues for a repair that reaches the attachment, not only the surface, and for a choice of covering that suits the wind.

A surface repair replaces the visible shingle and leaves the nails and sealant that failed beneath it. On a shore roof, that repair often holds for one season and then lifts again at the same point, because the cause was never reached.

A better repair checks the course beneath, reseals or renails the lifted row and replaces the metal at the edge if it has bent. That extra care belongs in the scope, set out line by line rather than folded into a single total.

Ask the roofer whether the covering on the house is suited to the exposure and whether a different one would hold better. Some coverings handle bay wind better than others, and the choice is worth making once, with the wind in mind, rather than repeating the same repair every few years.

What should a post-storm record on the bay include?

The record should include dated photographs from the ground and the attic, a list of findings and the repair agreed, all written down.

Photograph each finding before anything is repaired, from the ground and from the attic. The photographs are the baseline for the repair and the reference if the same area is damaged again, and they show the condition of the roof as it was when the storm ended.

Write down any temporary measure, such as a tarp or a board over a gap, with the date it went on. A temporary repair should be replaced by a permanent one on an agreed date, rather than left in place until it becomes the permanent repair by default.

Ask for the permanent scope in writing, with the permit question answered and any inspection noted. A post-storm repair recorded this way is far easier to check the next time the wind blows, and it protects the homeowner if a later failure is traced back to the same point.

Frequently asked questions

Do shingles on the bay side always fail first?

Not always, because the wind's direction changes in a storm. The windward edges fail most often, but a gale that turns can load a side that has been sheltered for years, so check all four sides after a big wind.

Is one lifted shingle a serious problem?

It can be. A single lifted tab often means the sealant has lost its hold or a nail has backed out, and the gap lets rain under the layer below. Have it reset and the neighboring tabs checked.

Does salt air wear out metal faster near the bay?

It can. Salt and spray work on fasteners, seams and finishes, and the wear shows as corrosion and loose panels before any other damage appears. A metal roof near the water is worth inspecting more often than one inland.

What should I describe when I call about wind damage?

Describe where the damage is, the direction of the strongest wind as you remember it, any covering you found in the yard and any water inside. Those details help the roofer decide what to bring to the visit.

Is Bob the storm to plan around on this coast?

It is the most recent of the reference storms for this coast, alongside the 1938 hurricane and Carol in 1954, and it is the one most people here remember. That makes it a practical yardstick for judging a shore roof.

This guide is general information for Bristol County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

Need help today?

Call any hour and explain what is going on. You get a clear price before any work starts.

Keep reading

More guides

What a three-story roof asks of a crew

A triple-decker is three stories of wall under a roof that is often flat, low-slope or hidden behind a parapet, with a rear ell and porch roofs beside it.

WhatsApp