Phones answered 24/7New Bedford, MA
Call (833) 751-2102
Phones answered 24/7Call any time(833) 751-2102
Guide

What winter weather does to the edge of a roof

What nor'easter snow, freeze-thaw cycles and ice dams do to eaves and gutters on South Coast roofs, and what an ice barrier is meant to do.

Illustration for the guide "What winter weather does to the edge of a roof" (New Bedford, MA)
Short answer

A nor'easter brings wind, rain and sometimes snow, and the freeze-thaw cycles that follow leave ice at the eaves. Ice dams push water under the covering, where it can reach the walls and ceilings. This guide explains how the damage forms, what an ice barrier is meant to do and what a roofer should check before the next winter.

Key takeaways

  • A nor'easter loads a roof with wind, rain and sometimes wet snow in the same event, and each load tests the roof differently.
  • Ice dams form when heat from the attic melts snow that refreezes at the cold eave, and the trapped meltwater works under the covering.
  • An ice barrier is a membrane under the covering at the eave, and it protects the deck while the ice melts; it does not stop a dam from forming.
  • Blocked gutters and downspouts hold water at the edge, and that water refreezes where it stands.
  • Ice damage and wind damage leave different marks in the attic, and a roofer should say which one is present.
  • Before winter, clear the gutters, check the attic air and insulation, and confirm the ice protection at the eave.

What is a nor'easter, and why does it matter for a roof?

A nor'easter drives wind from the northeast, and it can bring rain, snow and sustained wind to a roof in the same event.

A nor'easter is a coastal storm whose winds blow in from the northeast over the water. It can bring heavy rain, wet snow and strong sustained wind in the same event, and each of those loads a roof in a different way.

Wind loads the edges and the flashing. Rain tests the joints and the drainage. Wet snow adds weight to a low-slope deck and to the valleys where it collects. A roof can stand up to one of these and fail under another, so a check after a nor'easter should look at all three.

This guide does not print snow totals for the city, because no reliable New Bedford figure was found. The practical point holds whatever the total: the roof has to shed the snow and the water that comes with it, and it has to keep its edges fastened while it does.

How do ice dams form at the eave?

Heat escaping from the attic melts snow on the roof, and the meltwater refreezes at the cold eave, building a dam that holds water back under the covering.

Snow on a warm roof melts from below as heat leaks up from the living space through the ceiling and into the attic. The meltwater runs down the slope until it reaches the eave, which is colder because it projects past the wall, and there it refreezes.

The refrozen ice builds into a dam. Water that melts higher on the roof then has nowhere to go, so it pools behind the dam and works under the shingles, where it can reach the deck, the wall and the ceiling below.

Older attics are often tight, with little insulation at the top of the wall and little air moving through the space. A house that holds heat well on its lower floors can still lose a great deal of it through the attic, and that heat is what feeds the dam from underneath.

What does an ice barrier do?

An ice barrier is a membrane laid under the covering at the eave, and it keeps water that gets under the shingles from reaching the house.

The barrier is a self-adhering membrane laid under the covering along the eave and carried up the slope past the line of the wall. Its job is to stop water that backs up under the shingles from reaching the deck and the wall below.

The barrier does not stop the dam from forming, and it does not replace ventilation or insulation. It buys time and protects the decking while the ice melts, which is why it works best alongside a sound attic and clear gutters rather than on its own.

One roofing summary reports that the state code calls for an ice barrier statewide. That report was not checked against the text of the code, so ask the building department what the current code requires for a given roof.

What should a roofer check at the eave?

The roofer checks the eave for ice and staining, the gutters for blockage, the soffit vents for airflow and the flashing where the roof meets the wall.

Start at the eave from the ground or a safe ladder. Look for ice that has built a ridge over the edge, for icicles that show where water is leaving the roof, and for staining on the fascia or the soffit below. Those signs show where the water has been going.

Check the gutters and downspouts. A gutter packed with ice or leaves holds water at the edge and sends it back under the covering, and a downspout that discharges at the foundation can wet the wall and the cellar below it.

Check the soffit vents and the attic. Blocked soffit vents mean the attic air does not move, and warm, moist air from below feeds the dam from inside. Insulation pushed against the eave vent is a common cause, and it is simple to correct once it is found.

How do gutters and downspouts add to the problem?

Gutters that are blocked or pitched wrong hold water at the edge, and downspouts that discharge badly can refreeze on the walk or the wall.

A gutter is only as good as its drainage. Leaves, grit and ice fill the trough, and the water that should run to the downspout spills over the front edge or stays in the trough to freeze, which adds weight to the fascia.

On city lots with close neighbors, a downspout that drains onto the next lot or onto a walk can create ice that causes a problem of its own. Extending the downspout to carry water clear of the foundation is a simple step worth asking about.

Check the gutter brackets as well. A gutter pulled away from the fascia by the weight of ice will sag, hold water and fail at the joint. The fix is quicker when it is caught early, before the fascia behind it has begun to rot.

How do ice damage and wind damage look in the attic?

Ice damage leaves wet insulation and stained sheathing along the eave, while wind and rain damage tends to show as wet spots at specific points.

Ice dam damage tends to show along the eave, with stained sheathing, wet insulation pressed against the wall and dark edges on the rafters that follow the line of the dam. The pattern runs with the eave rather than with a single point.

Wind and rain damage tend to appear at a point, such as a lifted edge, a joint at a chimney or a split flashing, and the water follows from that point down the rafter. Telling the two apart matters, because the repairs are different.

A roofer who checks the attic before the outside should say which pattern is present and why. A dated photograph of each stain helps, and the stain should be marked for re-inspection after the next freeze so that its progress can be compared.

When should a homeowner call during a thaw?

Call when water appears on a ceiling during a thaw, when a dam is visible at the eave or when a gutter has pulled away from the fascia.

A thaw that follows a heavy snow is the moment when a dam is most likely to release its water into the house. A stain that appears on a ceiling during or just after a thaw is a call the same day, because it means water has already passed the covering.

A visible ice ridge at the eave, with water running behind it, is a call for the next available visit. It is not usually a reason to climb the roof. Describe where the ridge sits and where the water shows inside, and the crew can plan the visit.

Call (833) 751-2102 with the location, the date and a photograph if you have one. A roofer who knows where the dam formed can bring the right materials and can often reduce the water reaching the house before the next freeze.

What should a homeowner do before winter?

Clear the gutters, check the attic insulation and ventilation, confirm the ice protection at the eave and schedule an inspection in the fall.

In the fall, clear the gutters and downspouts and check that each downspout carries water clear of the house. Look into the attic through the hatch, and note any insulation that has moved against the eave or any sign of damp in the framing.

Ask a roofer to confirm the ice protection at the eave, including whether a barrier is present and how far it runs up the slope. A roof that lacks one, or has an old membrane that has aged, may need work at the eave, and that question should be settled before the snow comes.

Schedule a fall inspection with written findings. A dated record of the eave, the gutters and the attic gives the next winter a baseline, and it makes it easy to see whether a stain is new or was already present when the roof was checked.

Frequently asked questions

Will a roof with an ice barrier never have ice dams?

Not guaranteed. The barrier protects against water that gets under the covering, but it does not stop a dam forming. Ventilation and insulation in the attic reduce how much ice builds at the eave in the first place.

Should I climb up and knock ice off my roof?

No. Working on a snowy or icy roof is a serious fall risk, and tools used on the covering can cause a second problem. Call a roofer for ice and snow removal, and keep the gutters clear from the ground where it is safe to do so.

Why does my ceiling stain only after a thaw?

Ice dams hold water back for days, and the water works into the covering and the insulation. When the thaw comes, the trapped water reaches the ceiling, so the stain can appear well after the snow has fallen.

Does every nor'easter cause ice dams?

No. Ice dams need the right mix of snow on the roof, heat from the attic and cold at the eave. A storm that drops snow and is followed by a hard freeze is more likely to produce them than one that mostly rains.

Who decides whether my roof needs an ice barrier?

The state code and the building department decide what the current rules require for the work. Ask the roofer to show the requirement and the department to confirm it, because a secondary summary of the rule is not the code text itself.

This guide is general information for Bristol County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

One call and it gets handled.

Tell us when you need someone and we book the earliest visit a help technician has, and you approve the price before any work starts.

Keep reading

More guides

What a three-story roof asks of a crew

A triple-decker is three stories of wall under a roof that is often flat, low-slope or hidden behind a parapet, with a rear ell and porch roofs beside it.

WhatsApp